Sophie Hope's mortgage application was denied after her credit score plummeted due to identity fraud she did not know had occurred. Someone opened accounts in her name at catalogue sites and ordered items including a PlayStation 4 and Nike socks. The debt accumulated for three to four years before she discovered it while applying for a mortgage.

Credit scores in the UK are produced by three firms: Experian, Equifax and TransUnion. Funmi Olufunwa, a consumer finance lawyer, says credit scores are "backward looking" and do not necessarily predict future affordability. The system also disadvantages "thin-file applicants" such as young people and recent immigrants without established credit histories.

AI-powered lending firms Upstart and Zest AI offer lenders an alternative to traditional credit scoring. Upstart said in a statement that its machine-learning models analyse more than 2,500 variables and can "make significantly more loans at low prices to borrowers from every demographic group." Sarah Tucker, founder and CEO of The Mortgage Mum, says AI could help lenders analyse broader information sets and build more individual pictures of affordability and risk.

However, concerns exist about bias and accountability. Sandra Wachter, professor of Technology and Regulation at the University of Oxford, argues that AI does not account for existing social inequalities and could "replicate what it has seen in the past." She warns that without safeguards, AI use will "fortify, foster, and enhance discrimination."

Evangeline Atkinson co-founded Noggin HQ, a credit reference agency authorised by the FCA in June, after being unable to get a phone contract because she had no credit history with the big three agencies. Noggin HQ analyzes current account transactional data without using AI. Atkinson has argued AI "carries the risk of inbuilt bias" because "it would be very easy for the models to be inferring various kind of protected characteristics."

Experian announced a partnership with OpenAI in August 2026 allowing users to check their credit score in ChatGPT.